Jekyll Realty Reviews & Testimonials

We love to know what our guests are thinking, it helps us ensure we continue to deliver on our promises.

Explore past Jekyll Realty guest reviews and discover your perfect Jekyll Island vacation property. We appreciate your review once you have stayed with us!

To better serve you, we have been collecting and posting guest reviews to better assist in selecting the perfect vacation home. Read past Jekyll Realty guest reviews to discover your perfect Jekyll Island vacation property. No matter what you are looking for, we are sure to have it! Once you’ve stayed, we’d appreciate your review to pass along your experience to others. As always, if you have any questions about a property, please call 888-333-5055. Our experienced team knows every property and can assist with specific questions.

Property name:


Total reviews: 34

Comfortable Spacious Retreat

Stayed Apr 2024


Great place to relax and enjoy the island and it's amenities.

Comfortable Spacious Retreat Again

Timothy O.

Stayed Mar 2024


A great quiet place to be away from noise of people, traffic and activities.

Comfortable Spacious Retreat

Stayed Jan 2024


A great place to relax in comfortable surroundings and explore the beauty of Jekyll Island.

Arrive Duplex

Stayed Jan 2024


The property was very clean and comfortable. It was close to the beach and a short drive to downtown. We had an issue that was resolved immediately. Would definitely recommend.



Stayed Dec 2023


Jekyll Island is my favorite place to vacation for 63 plus years now. Most rentals have sufficed our needs and more. Any problems have always been "fixed". The seating in the LR at Arrival A is a first. The loveseats need to be thrown away, not even given to goodwill. The only comfortable place to relax was the beds. The natural part of the island that is left is as awesome as always. I pray that it will stay there and not be ruined by adding more buildings and complexes. The CHRISTmas decor was above and beyond, as far as display. So sad that there was not any part of it that celebrated that CHRISTmas is Jesus's birthday. Political correctness was at its best and that is very sad. Your service and staff were outstanding, as always. The bargain on the bike rental was greatly appreciated. I pray that the "powers that be" will not allow JI to turn into St Simons or Tybee. The only way I would rent Arrival A again would be with assurance that the LR sofas are replaced with decent replacements Thank you, "jekyllonmymind"

Arrive duplex was a favorite?

Rosemary D.

Stayed Nov 2023


This was our 3rd time renting Arrive duplex. We love the 1 level floor plan and the fact that it has 1 king bed and 1 queen bed. It is always clean and in walking distance to the beach.The only downfall to this unit is when we tried to rebook for another trip down first of the year, we were extremely disappointed that they had raised the price over $50 more per night. You are going to price yourself out of the market that you serve, being retired traveling folks like myself. Shame on you for that!

We were extremely pleased with Jekyll Island Property!!

Elizabeth K.

Stayed Sep 2023


We stayed in the beach house called Arrive! It was very clean and perfect for our week long visit! Everything was beyond amazing!!! I would definitely go through Jekyll Island Property & Sales Management, Inc. They are very helpful and nice! Every single time I called each person I spoke to in person or over the phone acted like they had known me forever! Love them!


Stayed Aug 2023


This is a nice unit and I would definitely stay here again.

Decent spot for short stay

Stayed Jul 2023


On the plus side , great location on a quiet street. Comfortably slept three. Kitchen needs to be outfitted with new cookware (frying pan and cooking sheet need replacing) and some basic necessities. There wasn’t even a bowl big enough to scramble eggs. Plenty of clean towels provided, but bring your own soaps and toilet paper. The place was tidy, but floors were grimy and need deep cleaning—we noticed the bottoms of our feet got black when we stepped out of the shower. Good experience with rental company. The dishwasher didn’t start and maintenance guy showed up five minutes after calling.

Perfect Escape!

Rachel C.

Stayed Apr 2023


Arrive was perfect for us. Two bedrooms and two full baths and a great screened in porch for relaxing in the evenings. The king bed in the master is firm, the queen bed is a little softer. The house has been nicely updated and feels open and airy. We love the location because it’s pretty central to everything and it’s easy to hop on your bikes and go. It’s a couple of blocks to the beach if you want to walk or an extremely short drive to the beach park. The house felt clean overall but whoever prepared it for our arrival didn’t do a good job cleaning crumbs from the windowsills and making sure the corners were swept out. This has been one of our favorite places to stay on Jekyll and we plan to be back.